Chris' Blog

Daily Digest

Free Content

The most recent Chris Martenson content available to all site visitors.

Daily Digest - November 20

Daily Digest - November 19

Daily Digest - November 18

Daily Digest - November 17

Daily Digest - November 16

Daily Digest - November 15

Daily Digest - November 14

Daily Digest - November 13

The Implications and Fallout of the IEA "Leaks"

Daily Digest - November 12

Login for Registered Members:

Register for Free

Post comments, receive updates via email, gain access to exclusive content, and more.

Global Climate Change: is it worth brushing off?

Subscribe to this feed
Bookmark and Share
474 replies [Last post]
affert
User offline. Last seen 1 day 5 hours ago. Offline
Bronze Member
Posts: 83
Joined: 09/22/2008
Global Climate Change: is it worth brushing off?

I would like to challenge the claim that there is very little consensus about Global Climate Change. 

A very complete, thoughtful look at the issue is available from the "How It All Ends" video series  (available on youtube). The series was put together after the author had his first video attacked by many climate change doubters.  The series covers every argument against climate change I'd ever heard before, and many that I'd not heard.  (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mF_anaVcCXg is the initial video).  The whole series is over 6 hours long, but is organized for people with certain types of objections can watch certain videos to hear their objections answered.  http://www.manpollo.org/education/objections/objections.html is a link that points individual objections to peices of the video series that address specific objections.I would recommend watching the first movie, then (if you don't think you have time to watch the whole thing) jump to those objections you have heard.

 

Please, Chris (and others) take a look at the evidence presented there.  We can't allow selfish or irrational people to distort or side-track the discussion about global climate change.This issue is essential.

Solgundy
User offline. Last seen 46 weeks 5 days ago. Offline
New Member
Posts: 1
Joined: 10/01/2008
Global Cooling...?
NASA Science News for September 30, 2008 Astronomers who count sunspots have announced that 2008 has become the "blankest year" of the Space Age. Sunspot counts are at a 50-year low, signifying a deep minimum in the 11-year cycle of solar activity. FULL STORY at http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2008/... ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SDF Number 274 Issued at 2200Z on 30 Sep 2008 Analysis of Solar Active Regions and Activity from 29/2100Z to 30/2100Z: Solar activity was at very low levels. Solar Activity Forecast: Solar activity is expected to remain at very low levels. updated daily: http://www.solarcycle24.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Global warming hype could be masking a more immediate climate problem. A problem that could have a larger impact on our lives than global warming over the next 20 years. Solar scientists have predicted the return of the Dalton Minimum, which was the result of two low intensity sunspot cycles lasting over 28 years. During the early 1800s the average temperatures in the Mid West were 2-4 degrees cooler than the 20th Century average. In many areas it was much dryer than average, especially along the California coast. We have already started to see some ocean cooling as we leave sunspot cycle 23 and enter sunspot cycle 24, the first of the two predicted minimum cycles. http://sesfoundation.org/dalton_minimum.... --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1400-1520 ? cold (Sporer minimum) 1520-1640 107 warm 1640-1700 61 cold (Maunder minimum) 1700-1805 114 warm 1805-1925 95 cold (Dalton minimum) 1925-2010 138 warm 2010-2110 ? cold? 200 yr sun spot cycle http://www.kolumbus.fi/tilmari/some200.h... ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Peak Oil??...........then this.....omg
its only money
User offline. Last seen 34 weeks 2 days ago. Offline
New Member
Posts: 1
Joined: 09/24/2008
less spots on the sun
gees solgundy,i'm getting a mite stressed here,for starters the economy appears to be slowing and on a personel level my shares in lehman aren't doing well,there's a war going on somewhere and thats not good and those pesky terrorists are still up to miscief.double gees,don't you read the newspapers.less spots on the sun,dear o me,the sun is a long way away and can't possibly affect you or me so shrug it off .sorry to be so harsh on you man but don't distract us,the serious thinkers,from the main game.the news on the economy is not looking good,i'd even say its a long way from good,worry about that instead.on a brighter note when peak oil gets here and production reaches a zenith there'll be so much and so cheap that the increased carbon emissions will offset your concerns about global cooling.hope this helps.
affert
User offline. Last seen 1 day 5 hours ago. Offline
Bronze Member
Posts: 83
Joined: 09/22/2008
""There is also the matter

""There is also the matter of solar irradiance," adds Pesnell. "Researchers are now seeing the dimmest sun in their records. The change is small, just a fraction of a percent, but significant. Questions about effects on climate are natural if the sun continues to dim." ~Quote from first article.  

I don't claim to know a lot about sun spots, but if this is true (that global temperatures are being pushed down by low levels of solar activity) that is disturbing.  Here's why: a number of effects mask the upward pressure that CO2 is putting on global temperatures.  Solar dimming is one (which is air pollution reflecting some of the sun's energy back into space).   If the solar dimming effect is further helped by a low in sunspot activity, that means the effect of greenhouse gases are even larger than we've already measured.  

So if a lull in solar activity is happening right now, it will keep temperatures lower now than they would be (good in the short run), but once the sun returns to a normal level of activity, the temperature will jump up.   

stocks321's picture
stocks321
User offline. Last seen 2 days 11 hours ago. Offline
Bronze Member
Posts: 91
Joined: 07/12/2008
Re: Global Climate Change: is it worth brushing off?
As a research physicist who has spent the past 30 years of my career in atmospheric science, I am surprised that government agencies, politicians, and much of the public have been manipulated by a political agenda with no scientific basis, which is the best way to describe the "non-link" between CO2 and global warming. There is virtually NO physical science to support any role of man's generation of Carbon Dioxide (CO2) in climate change. All of this pseudo-science is driven by poorly conceived computer modeling and represents a political agenda that uses science and the public as pawns.

Carbon Dioxide is critical for plant life and therefore to animal life and to regulate it as a pollutant is a total misunderstanding of its role in life and the role that man plays in the environment. Rather than restating all of the scientific arguments I suggest that you contact Senator James Inhofe's EPW Committee staff member, Marc Morano, who has done an excellent job of collecting an overwhelming amount of peer-reviewed science (see: here) that clearly demonstrates that there is no basis for the EPA to regulate Carbon Dioxide.

Since Carbon Dioxide is such a minor greenhouse gas compared to water vapor it would make much more scientific sense for the EPA to regulate HUMIDITY! To regulate Carbon Dioxide empowers the creation of a carbon trading scheme that is, in essence, the trading of hot air. In fact, carbon trading makes even less sense than the trading of derivatives by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

As global temperatures continue to drop I would think that the last thing that the EPA would want to do is to be responsible for another trillion dollar economic disaster. From my perspective, there appear to be many more top scientists who do NOT believe in AGW and CO2 as a critical element in climate change and see that the SUN is the active determinant for climate.



Comments sent to EPA by research physicist John W. Brosnahan of Vanderpool, Texas, who develops remote-sensing instruments for atmospheric science for such clients as NOAA and NASA and who has published much peer-reviewed research. Brosnahan has given permission for public release of his statement


New Peer-Reviewed Scientific Studies Chill Global Warming Fears

Washington DC – An abundance of new peer-reviewed studies, analyses, and data error discoveries in the last several months has prompted scientists to declare that fear of catastrophic man-made global warming “bites the dust” and the scientific underpinnings for alarm may be “falling apart.” The latest study to cast doubt on climate fears finds that even a doubling of atmospheric carbon dioxide would not have the previously predicted dire impacts on global temperatures. This new study is not unique, as a host of recent peer-reviewed studies have cast a chill on global warming fears.

http://epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?Fus...3a-b35d0842fed8
__________________

The desire to save humanity is always a false front for the urge to rule it.  - H L Mencken

Science advances one funeral at a time  - Max Planck

Environmentalist doomsayers are a logical outgrowth of religious apocalyptics

                                                                       

RubberRims's picture
RubberRims
User offline. Last seen 28 weeks 17 hours ago. Offline
Silver Member
Posts: 141
Joined: 11/22/2008
Re: Global Climate Change: is it worth brushing off?

 

stocks321 where have you been hiding? God I thought I was alone trying to tell people about the truth.

Keep your presence on this site, we are going to need your direct knowledge in order to dispel the Global Worming mith witch has been sold to people like a cheap suit. If it fits wear it.

Thanks nice thread

__________________

If you think it is possible to understand media then remember why abstract art is a function and not a reality. What the eye sees the mind nearly always believes. The Government should create, issue, and circulate all the currency and credits needed to satisfy the spending power of the Government and the buying power of consumers. By the adoption of these principles, the taxpayers will be saved immense sums of interest. Money will cease to be master and become the servant of humanity.

stocks321's picture
stocks321
User offline. Last seen 2 days 11 hours ago. Offline
Bronze Member
Posts: 91
Joined: 07/12/2008
Re: Global Climate Change: is it worth brushing off?
Solar science forum poll -- Is global cooling on the way?

Yes -- 76 votes
No -- 7 votes

We can thus almost be sure that the cycle 23 has ended, but despite the fact that the cycle 24 has clearly started, the rise has been so slow, that we can be pretty sure that the cycle will be very low, which in the past always has meant a colder climate.

http://solarcycle24com.proboards106.com/in...ad=7&page=3



Very cool solar science website:

http://www.solarcycle24.com/
__________________

The desire to save humanity is always a false front for the urge to rule it.  - H L Mencken

Science advances one funeral at a time  - Max Planck

Environmentalist doomsayers are a logical outgrowth of religious apocalyptics

                                                                       

AlanPage's picture
AlanPage
User offline. Last seen 20 weeks 4 days ago. Offline
New Member
Posts: 12
Joined: 09/04/2008
Re: Global Climate Change: is it worth brushing off?

We have an interesting collection of view points here!

Little will be accomplished by trying to debate the source of problems on this site where we have limited access to factual material except through the links that we add ourselves. I would like to see a portion of the site to be at least a list of links to important technical material that relates to each chapter of the CC.

Since Chris started by basing the CC on his beliefs, I am going to add a few here

1) Whether CO2 is antropomorphic or not its atmospheric concentration is out of control as evidenced by the exponential curve of CO2 concentration measured by Charles Keeling and others.

2) Whether CO2 is antropomorphic or not its oceanic concentration is beyond the marine buffer capacity to hold the pH of seawater at a constant level. Researchers are documenting an order of magnitude change in pH with devastating results to coral, shell fish, and marine microorganisms.

3) Arctic research (recently severly cut back by our administration) has reported rapidly increasing Arctic sea ice melting to the extent that the Arctic Ocean may be free of ice with in less than ten years.

4) The same research vessels are witnessing high (100x normal) methane concentrations along the continental shelf area and inland over permafrost that is now melting. Infrastructure in northern regions is collapsing where the permafrost is melting.

5) In past climate change situations CO3 was not a driver but the result of other change vectors. Today we are adding forcing agents to the system that may show up eventually in surprising ways.

These major tipping point situations may already be placing unrecognized forcing in the pipeline as affert noted.

I suggest that these situations are worthy of our consideration in light of the many other "J" or "reverse J" shaped exponential factors that are going to influence our ability to support the variety of life that brought us to this point. We have no right to purposefully destroy the oceans as a place for corals and clams and mussels etc to live and filter that water. We have a responsibility to safe guard the ability of the planet to support our progeny. We have the responsibility to repair the easy picking that Chris has described in his discussions of nonrenewable resources.

We have an interesting opportunity to repair the possibility of local sustainablle communities again being able to support their local populations without reliance on imports from outside the region. I suggest that you search: "SWAT Team" in the search box above and read the comments. If this the way the rich and powerful aare going to approach this period of change that Chris advocates our embracing we are in for a HELL of a fight! And the enviroment will be the battleground that dies first.

 

 

__________________

We need to remember that nature uses compounding to a point and then disables it for all entities which allows everything to start over on the refuse of the past.

Damnthematrix's picture
Damnthematrix
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 34 min ago. Offline
Diamond Member
Posts: 1953
Joined: 08/10/2008
Re: ""There is also the matter
affert wrote:
""There is also the matter of solar irradiance," adds Pesnell. "Researchers are now seeing the dimmest sun in their records. The change is small, just a fraction of a percent, but significant. Questions about effects on climate are natural if the sun continues to dim." ~Quote from first article.

The sun is dimming.  But the last time I saw figures on this (and I submerge myself in this stuff) it was by some utterly measly figure like 0.1%....  I will try and find out the article/link 

Damnthematrix's picture
Damnthematrix
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 34 min ago. Offline
Diamond Member
Posts: 1953
Joined: 08/10/2008
Re: less spots on the sun

its only money wrote:
gees solgundy,i'm getting a mite stressed here,for starters the economy appears to be slowing and on a personel level my shares in lehman aren't doing well,there's a war going on somewhere and thats not good and those pesky terrorists are still up to miscief.double gees,don't you read the newspapers.less spots on the sun,dear o me,the sun is a long way away and can't possibly affect you or me so shrug it off .sorry to be so harsh on you man but don't distract us,the serious thinkers,from the main game.the news on the economy is not looking good,i'd even say its a long way from good,worry about that instead.on a brighter note when peak oil gets here and production reaches a zenith there'll be so much and so cheap that the increased carbon emissions will offset your concerns about global cooling.hope this helps.

It's only money...  hey? Well I think you're worrying about all the wrong things, forget your money and investaments, worry about this:

 

Recession, Depression and Shortages as Opportunities

Along with the terms recession and depression, have you noticed that the word "shortage" has  been popping up in the headlines more frequently? I have and it ranges from winter tire stortages in Quebec to propane shortages and crop spoilage in North Dakota. One blog even predicts regional food shortages  in the USA in 2009

Google the word "shortage" and you get 31,854 hits; "shortages" turn up  19,767 hits

Anticipating future changes, resulting consequences and potential shortages can provide opportunities for opportunity-savvy  and anticipatory-thinking entrepreneurs. 

  • Food shortages> gene-altered crops
  • Doctor shortages> telemedicine, remote robotics via telemedicine etc
  • Road salt shortages>beet juice, other natural alternatives
  • Cash shortages> pawn brokers, Loan sharking (Illegal)
  • Personnel shortages in startups> glut of laidoff employees
  • Price-increase triggered shortages (ie cement, conventional building technology) > smart technology substitutes (smart cement or contour crafting)
  • Power shortages in 3d world countries India, China> energy alternatives
  • Parking shortages>smart meters

Over  a dozen different tactics can address shortage scenarios (substitution, leap-frogging, reduction, elimination, co-production, brokering/ matchmaking, bring in from abroad, dealing with counterfeit products knocksoffs, vacume circumstances & opportunties, left behind scenarios, natural triggers, triggering trigger events  etc) and entrepreneurs should explore these to see if each is viable for them. ( see Opportunity Recognition Master Class and Do you know how to spot business opportunities? and Smart Technology Opportunities from my talk at VTT in Finland.


Walter Derzko, Smart Economy, Toronto

Damnthematrix's picture
Damnthematrix
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 34 min ago. Offline
Diamond Member
Posts: 1953
Joined: 08/10/2008
Re: Global Climate Change: is it worth brushing off?

stocks321 wrote:
Solar science forum poll -- Is global cooling on the way?

Yes -- 76 votes
No -- 7 votes

So then explain why all the world's glaciers and polar caps are melting....?  At rates never seen before? 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.